Cakes and desserts in the New York area: prices and online booking

169 cake and dessert makers serve the New York area in this index. 47 publish a price; the middle half start between $10 and $280. 2 show open dates or take bookings online.

The Runup runs this index. The Runup sells booking software that gives vendors the features this score rewards, so vendors on The Runup will score high, and they are labelled "Runs on The Runup". Vendors can score high without The Runup. The score measures how easily an AI assistant can find, price and book a vendor, not the quality of their work. Facts come from each vendor's website; confirm with the vendor before booking.

VendorPrice fromTypical priceAreas servedEvent typesOpen dates onlineInstant quoteBook onlineBookability scoreChecked
His & Her Favors $280 $280 to $775 New York City Weddings Not shown Not shown Yes 62 / 100 2026-11-13
Rustik Cake Studio $595 Hamptons, East End Weddings Not shown Not shown Yes 59 / 100 2026-11-13
Brooklyn Cake $5 $7 to $12 New York City, parts of Long Island, Hudson Valley, New Jersey Weddings, Birthdays Not shown Not shown Not shown 44 / 100 2026-11-13
Cake Fiction $10 $10 to $15 Tri-State area, within about 100 miles of Long Valley, NJ Weddings, Showers, Corporate events Not shown Not shown Not shown 44 / 100 2026-11-13
Fancy Cakes $175 Freehold, NJ and up to 3 hours away, NYC Weddings Not shown Not shown Not shown 44 / 100 2026-11-13
Kimmy's Kakes $6 $6 to $15 Essex County, NJ Weddings, Birthdays, Showers Not shown Not shown Not shown 44 / 100 2026-11-13
Cake Power $10 $10 to $20 Manhattan Weddings Not shown Not shown Not shown 41 / 100 2026-11-13
Simply Sweets By Lauren/ Cake Studio $400 Central Jersey Weddings, Corporate events, Other private events Not shown Yes Not shown 41 / 100 2026-11-13
Cake Hero $2,000 Greater New York Area Weddings, Birthdays Not shown Not shown Not shown 38 / 100 2026-11-13
CMNY Cakes $8 Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx Weddings, Bar and bat mitzvahs, Corporate events, Birthdays, Showers, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 38 / 100 2026-11-13
Doc’s Cake Shop $50 $50 to $300 New York, surrounding states Weddings, Corporate events, Birthdays Not shown Not shown Not shown 38 / 100 2026-11-13
MDV Custom Cakes, LLC $500 tri-state area Weddings, Showers Not shown Not shown Not shown 38 / 100 2026-11-13
My Daughter's Cakes $700 Northern New Jersey, New York City, Westchester, Long Island Weddings, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 38 / 100 2026-11-13
One Girl Cookies $50 Manhattan, Brooklyn Corporate events Not shown Not shown Not shown 38 / 100 2026-11-13
Pure Sugar, Inc $200 Long Island, the Hamptons, Montauk, Manhattan Weddings, Bar and bat mitzvahs, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 38 / 100 2026-11-13
Bleu Royale Cakes $275 $275 to $975 NYC Not shown Not shown Not shown 36 / 100 2026-11-13
Cake & Co. $150 North Jersey Weddings, Bar and bat mitzvahs Not shown Not shown Not shown 35 / 100 2026-11-13
Cakes By Faith $10 Brooklyn Weddings, Birthdays, Showers, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 35 / 100 2026-11-13
A Little Cake $320 New Jersey, New York, Connecticut, Bergen County, NJ Weddings, Birthdays, Showers, Bar and bat mitzvahs, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 32 / 100 2026-11-13
Ben-Israel Ron Cakes $20 New York City, East Coast Weddings, Birthdays, Bar and bat mitzvahs, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 32 / 100 2026-11-13
Cafe Pierrot $6 Sussex County, NJ, Northern New Jersey Birthdays, Showers, Corporate events, Weddings Not shown Not shown Not shown 32 / 100 2026-11-13
Cakes by Claire $220 Manhattan (below 100th Street), Brooklyn (above Prospect Park), Queens (up to Flushing) Corporate events Not shown Not shown Not shown 32 / 100 2026-11-13
CustomCookies.com $5 nationwide Weddings, Bar and bat mitzvahs, Showers Not shown Not shown Not shown 32 / 100 2026-11-13
Flowerbake by Angela $3 New York City metro area, Westchester Weddings, Birthdays, Showers, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 32 / 100 2026-11-13
Four & Twenty Blackbirds $46 Brooklyn, Manhattan, Queens Weddings, Corporate events, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 32 / 100 2026-11-13
From Lucie $525 East Village, Manhattan, within two hours by car for delivery Birthdays, Weddings, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 32 / 100 2026-11-13
petite fleur cake $10 Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, Long Island Weddings, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 32 / 100 2026-11-13
SOMA Cakes NYC $500 New York City Corporate events, Weddings, Birthdays Not shown Not shown Not shown 32 / 100 2026-11-13
Sweet Melissa Goodness Cafe $5 Ocean County, NJ, Atlantic County, NJ, Monmouth County, NJ, Burlington County, NJ Weddings, Birthdays, Showers, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 32 / 100 2026-11-13
The Evercake $245 NYC, Local New Jersey, the Hamptons Weddings, Birthdays, Showers, Corporate events, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 32 / 100 2026-11-13
The Vintage Cake $4 New Jersey, New York City Weddings Not shown Not shown Not shown 32 / 100 2026-11-13
Cakes By Klein $175 Manhattan Weddings, Birthdays Not shown Not shown Not shown 29 / 100 2026-11-13
Cups Cakes $45 Central Jersey Birthdays, Weddings, Showers, Bar and bat mitzvahs, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 29 / 100 2026-11-13
Krisota's Cake Shop $500 North Jersey Weddings, Birthdays Not shown Not shown Not shown 29 / 100 2026-11-13
Sweet Passion Cakery $350 North Jersey Weddings Not shown Not shown Not shown 29 / 100 2026-11-13
The Modern Cakery $280 North Jersey Weddings, Birthdays, Showers, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 29 / 100 2026-11-13
Victoria's Cake $250 North Jersey Birthdays, Showers, Weddings, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 29 / 100 2026-11-13
Vincenzo Salvatore Cakes $2,000 Weddings Not shown Not shown Not shown 29 / 100 2026-11-13
A Pound & A Half: Cookies and Cupcakes Inc $30 Long Island Not shown Not shown Not shown 27 / 100 2026-11-13
Keremo Cakes $7 New Jersey, New York Weddings, Birthdays, Showers, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 26 / 100 2026-11-13
leannescakes $250 Long Island, the 5 boroughs, coastal Connecticut Weddings, Birthdays, Showers, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 26 / 100 2026-11-13
Made in Heaven Cakes $10 Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, Staten Island Weddings, Birthdays, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 26 / 100 2026-11-13
Mark Joseph Cakes $8 tri-state area Weddings Not shown Not shown Not shown 26 / 100 2026-11-13
Mrs. B's Cakes $6 New Jersey, New York Weddings, Birthdays, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 26 / 100 2026-11-13
The Black Cake Company $80 New York Tri-state area Weddings, Corporate events Not shown Not shown Not shown 26 / 100 2026-11-13
Coco Luxe Pastry $65 Weddings Not shown Not shown Not shown 23 / 100 2026-11-13
Dulce Cakes & Desserts $135 North Jersey Corporate events Not shown Not shown Not shown 23 / 100 2026-11-13
A Cuter Cupcake Company Not found New York City, nationwide Birthdays, Showers, Weddings, Corporate events Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
Ali Cake Decorations By Alibet Llc Not found Union City, NJ, Guttenberg, NJ Birthdays, Showers, Weddings, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
AnnTremet Cake Not found Manhattan, Queens, Brooklyn, Long Island Birthdays Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
Cake Lush Not found Miami, South Florida Weddings, Birthdays, Corporate events, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
Camz Creations Not found Staten Island, NY and surrounding areas Birthdays, Weddings, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
Capy Tres Leches Cake Not found Queens, Brooklyn Birthdays, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
Cee Cee's Cupcake Palace Not found Freehold, NJ Birthdays, Weddings, Showers, Corporate events, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
Chefmorenoscakesllc Not found Brooklyn Weddings, Birthdays, Corporate events, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
Chocolate Carousel Not found Wall Township, NJ, New Jersey statewide Weddings, Corporate events, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
City Cakes Not found New York City, NY/NJ tri-state Weddings, Birthdays, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
Cocoa Bakery Not found Jersey City, Hudson County, New Jersey Weddings, Birthdays, Showers, Corporate events, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
Cocos Cakery Not found New Jersey Weddings, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
Create A Cake Not found Long Island Weddings Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
Cupcake Me Not found New York City Birthdays, Weddings, Showers, Corporate events, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
Cupcakes & Everything Chocolate Not found North Fork, Long Island Weddings, Showers, Birthdays Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
Dortoni Bakery Not found Long Island Weddings Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
Florie's Finales Not found Long Island, nationwide Weddings, Birthdays Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
Let Them Eat Cake Not found nationwide Corporate events Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
Maddalena's Cheesecake & Catering Not found Ringoes, NJ, Flemington, NJ, Hillsborough Township, NJ, Pennington, NJ Weddings, Corporate events, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
Mama's Custom Cookies Not found nationwide Weddings, Corporate events, Birthdays Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
N.Y. Cake Not found New York City, Chelsea, Manhattan Showers, Birthdays, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
Palermo Custom Cakes and Bakery Not found New Jersey Weddings, Birthdays Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
Red Rose Bakery Not found New Jersey Weddings, Showers Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
Saint Street Cakes Not found Brooklyn, East Hampton, the Catskills, New Jersey Weddings, Birthdays Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
Smallcakes Not found nationwide Birthdays, Showers, Weddings Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
Sugar Sugar Custom Cakes Not found Long Island, Farmingdale, NY, Quogue, NY Weddings Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
The Boozy Cupcake Shop Not found Astoria, across the city Birthdays, Weddings, Corporate events Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
The Purple Cupcake Not found Allentown, NJ, Upper Freehold, NJ, Robbinsville, NJ, Hamilton, NJ Birthdays, Weddings, Showers, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
Wild Flour Bakery Not found New York City Weddings, Corporate events, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
Wildly Cakes & Sweets Llc Not found Westchester, NY Birthdays, Weddings, Showers, Corporate events Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
Yip Studio Not found Brooklyn, Manhattan Weddings, Corporate events Not shown Not shown Not shown 14 / 100 2026-11-13
A Cake Baked in Brooklyn Not found South Florida Not shown Not shown Not shown 12 / 100 2026-11-13
Cappie Cakes Not found Nutley, NJ Not shown Not shown Not shown 12 / 100 2026-11-13
Doughnut Plant Not found New York City Not shown Not shown Not shown 12 / 100 2026-11-13
Mortgage Apple Cakes Not found Northern NJ, NYC metro area Not shown Not shown Not shown 12 / 100 2026-11-13
Polkadot Cake Shop Not found NJ, NY Not shown Not shown Not shown 12 / 100 2026-11-13
Sinfully Sweet Candy Buffet Not found tri-state area Not shown Not shown Not shown 12 / 100 2026-11-13
Archie's Best Desserts and Cake Not found Queens Other private events, Birthdays, Corporate events, Showers, Bar and bat mitzvahs Not shown Not shown Not shown 11 / 100 2026-11-13
Buttermilk Bakeshop Not found Weddings, Birthdays Not shown Not shown Not shown 11 / 100 2026-11-13
Cake On Heels Not found Central Jersey Birthdays, Weddings, Showers, Corporate events Not shown Not shown Not shown 11 / 100 2026-11-13
Cakes - Jenni Cakes Not found Central Jersey Weddings, Showers, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 11 / 100 2026-11-13
Copcakes Arresting Appetites Not found Long Island Birthdays, Showers Not shown Not shown Not shown 11 / 100 2026-11-13
Creative Cakes Not found Manhattan Birthdays, Bar and bat mitzvahs Not shown Not shown Not shown 11 / 100 2026-11-13
Custom Cakes by Kristy, Inc. Not found Long Island Weddings Not shown Not shown Not shown 11 / 100 2026-11-13
De Lor Cakery Not found Brooklyn Birthdays, Weddings, Corporate events Not shown Not shown Not shown 11 / 100 2026-11-13
Diamond Cakes Bakeshop Not found Long Island Birthdays, Showers, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 11 / 100 2026-11-13
Dough Not found Weddings, Birthdays, Corporate events, Showers Not shown Not shown Not shown 11 / 100 2026-11-13
Empire Cake Not found Manhattan Birthdays, Weddings, Showers, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 11 / 100 2026-11-13
Grace Kelli Cupcakes Not found Manhattan Corporate events Not shown Not shown Not shown 11 / 100 2026-11-13
Lael Cakes Not found Weddings, Birthdays, Corporate events, Showers, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 11 / 100 2026-11-13
Pattycakes Not found North Jersey Weddings, Showers, Birthdays, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 11 / 100 2026-11-13
Pink Little Cake Not found Central Jersey Weddings, Birthdays, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 11 / 100 2026-11-13
Polka Dot Pound Cake Not found Long Island Birthdays, Showers, Other private events, Corporate events Not shown Not shown Not shown 11 / 100 2026-11-13
Sarah & Simon Cake Design Not found Brooklyn Weddings Not shown Not shown Not shown 11 / 100 2026-11-13
Shero Cakes Not found Queens Weddings, Birthdays Not shown Not shown Not shown 11 / 100 2026-11-13
Sistaz cakes Not found Manhattan Weddings, Birthdays Not shown Not shown Not shown 11 / 100 2026-11-13
Suzi's Cakes Not found North Jersey Weddings, Birthdays Not shown Not shown Not shown 11 / 100 2026-11-13
Sweet Roots Cakery Not found Central Jersey Birthdays, Showers, Weddings, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 11 / 100 2026-11-13
Wildberrycake Not found Brooklyn Birthdays, Weddings, Showers, Corporate events Not shown Not shown Not shown 11 / 100 2026-11-13
Butter Me Up Not found Central Jersey Not shown Not shown Not shown 9 / 100 2026-11-13
Cakes by Nerwan Not found Queens Not shown Not shown Not shown 9 / 100 2026-11-13
Cakes With Character Not found Long Island Not shown Not shown Not shown 9 / 100 2026-11-13
Conti’s Pastry Shoppe Not found Not shown Not shown Not shown 9 / 100 2026-11-13
Donut Pub Not found Not shown Not shown Not shown 9 / 100 2026-11-13
Junior's Cheesecake Not found Queens Not shown Not shown Not shown 9 / 100 2026-11-13
Karla Jimenez Cakes and More Not found North Jersey Not shown Not shown Not shown 9 / 100 2026-11-13
Mery Cake Not found North Jersey Not shown Not shown Not shown 9 / 100 2026-11-13
Mr. Cupcakes Not found North Jersey Not shown Not shown Not shown 9 / 100 2026-11-13
Robyn's Sweet Boutique Not found Central Jersey Not shown Not shown Not shown 9 / 100 2026-11-13
The Chocolate Room Not found Not shown Not shown Not shown 9 / 100 2026-11-13
The One Cake Shop Not found Long Island Not shown Not shown Not shown 9 / 100 2026-11-13
Audrey's Fine Baked Goods Not found Long Island, New York tri-state area Birthdays, Weddings Not shown Not shown Not shown 8 / 100 2026-11-13
Ava's Cupcakes Not found Clemmons, NC, Winston-Salem, NC Birthdays, Weddings, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 8 / 100 2026-11-13
Beach Bakery Not found Westhampton Beach, surrounding communities Birthdays, Corporate events, Weddings, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 8 / 100 2026-11-13
City Sweets & Confections Not found New York City Weddings Not shown Not shown Not shown 8 / 100 2026-11-13
Experience Creativitee Not found Staten Island, Central New Jersey, Tri-state area Showers Not shown Not shown Not shown 8 / 100 2026-11-13
Front Street Bakery Not found Rockville Centre Birthdays, Showers, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 8 / 100 2026-11-13
Gladis Bakery Not found Union City, NJ, New Jersey, New York, Connecticut Weddings, Birthdays, Showers, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 8 / 100 2026-11-13
Molly's Cupcakes Not found Chicago, New York, Iowa, Ohio Weddings, Corporate events, Birthdays, Showers, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 8 / 100 2026-11-13
Purple Cow Cakery Not found New Jersey, New York City Weddings, Showers, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 8 / 100 2026-11-13
Snooky's Custom Cakes Not found New York City Birthdays, Weddings, Bar and bat mitzvahs, Showers Not shown Not shown Not shown 8 / 100 2026-11-13
Sugar Couture Not found New York City, nationwide shipping Weddings, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 8 / 100 2026-11-13
Sweet Sweet Sues Custom Cakes Not found Staten Island, Manhattan, Brooklyn, Bronx Weddings, Birthdays, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 8 / 100 2026-11-13
Taipan Bakery Not found Manhattan Chinatown, Queens Flushing Birthdays, Weddings Not shown Not shown Not shown 8 / 100 2026-11-13
The Cakery Bake Shop Not found New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, Pennsylvania Weddings, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 8 / 100 2026-11-13
Baked NYC Not found Brooklyn, Queens, Manhattan, Bronx (sometimes) Not shown Not shown No 6 / 100 2026-11-13
BKLYN Cake Studio Not found Park Slope, Windsor Terrace, Kensington, other areas by distance Not shown Not shown Not shown 6 / 100 2026-11-13
Oh.sweet.mason [desserts, Custom Birthday Cake & Specialty Cupcakes] Not found New York Not shown Not shown Not shown 6 / 100 2026-11-13
AwesomeYo’s Kitchen & Cakes Not found Central Jersey Birthdays, Weddings Not shown Not shown Not shown 5 / 100 2026-11-13
BCakeNY Not found Brooklyn Birthdays, Showers, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 5 / 100 2026-11-13
Cameo Cakes Gourmet Bakery Not found Central Jersey Weddings, Birthdays Not shown Not shown Not shown 5 / 100 2026-11-13
Capy Tres Leches Cake - Corona Not found Queens Birthdays, Weddings, Showers, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 5 / 100 2026-11-13
Frosted Flour Cake Shop Not found Central Jersey Birthdays, Weddings Not shown Not shown Not shown 5 / 100 2026-11-13
Icing On The Cake Not found Manhattan Weddings Not shown Not shown Not shown 5 / 100 2026-11-13
Ladybird Bakery Not found Weddings Not shown Not shown Not shown 5 / 100 2026-11-13
Merrie Stone-Ober Not found Weddings, Showers Not shown Not shown Not shown 5 / 100 2026-11-13
Muller's Bakery Not found Weddings Not shown Not shown Not shown 5 / 100 2026-11-13
Palermo's Bakery Not found Weddings, Birthdays, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 5 / 100 2026-11-13
S Cake Not found Brooklyn Birthdays, Weddings, Showers, Corporate events Not shown Not shown Not shown 5 / 100 2026-11-13
Sugar Magnolias Not found Long Island Corporate events, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 5 / 100 2026-11-13
Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery Not found Birthdays, Corporate events, Weddings, Showers, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 5 / 100 2026-11-13
The Cake Don Not found Long Island Weddings, Birthdays Not shown Not shown Not shown 5 / 100 2026-11-13
Twisted Sisters Cupcakery Not found Central Jersey Birthdays, Weddings Not shown Not shown Not shown 5 / 100 2026-11-13
Venieros Not found Weddings, Birthdays, Corporate events, Other private events Not shown Not shown Not shown 5 / 100 2026-11-13
Cake Parlour Not found Queens Not shown Not shown Not shown 3 / 100 2026-11-13
Cupcake Cafe Not found North Jersey Not shown Not shown Not shown 3 / 100 2026-11-13
Cupcake Magician Not found Central Jersey Not shown Not shown Not shown 3 / 100 2026-11-13
Cupcakes By Carousel Not found North Jersey Not shown Not shown Not shown 3 / 100 2026-11-13
House of Cupcakes Not found Central Jersey Not shown Not shown Not shown 3 / 100 2026-11-13
Jackie's Sweets | Coffee Shop & Dominican Cakes Not found Central Jersey Not shown Not shown Not shown 3 / 100 2026-11-13
JB Couture Cupcakes Not found Central Jersey Not shown Not shown Not shown 3 / 100 2026-11-13
Little Cupcake Bakeshop Not found Manhattan Not shown Not shown Not shown 3 / 100 2026-11-13
Lucy's Not found Brooklyn Not shown Not shown Not shown 3 / 100 2026-11-13
Sprinkles Cupcakes Not found Manhattan Not shown Not shown Not shown 3 / 100 2026-11-13
Tori Cakes Not found North Jersey Not shown Not shown Not shown 3 / 100 2026-11-13
Chip City Not found Queens Not shown Not shown Not shown 0 / 100 2026-11-13
E's Cake Shop Not found Brooklyn Not shown Not shown Not shown 0 / 100 2026-11-13
Elegant Wedding Cakes Not found Central Jersey Not shown Not shown Not shown 0 / 100
Let Them Eat Cake Not found Brooklyn Not shown Not shown Not shown 0 / 100
Sweet Life Cupcakes Not found North Jersey Not shown Not shown Not shown 0 / 100
Sweet Sisters Cakes Not found North Jersey Not shown Not shown Not shown 0 / 100
Sweethaus Cupcake Cafe Not found Brooklyn Not shown Not shown Not shown 0 / 100

Related pages

Sorted by fit: vendors with a published price and online booking first, then by score. Being on The Runup does not change the order.