Cakes and desserts in Long Island: prices and online booking
27 cake and dessert makers in this index are based in Long Island or name it among the areas they serve. 10 publish a price; the middle half start between $9 and $336. 1 show open dates or take bookings online.
The Runup runs this index. The Runup sells booking software that gives vendors the features this score rewards, so vendors on The Runup will score high, and they are labelled "Runs on The Runup". Vendors can score high without The Runup. The score measures how easily an AI assistant can find, price and book a vendor, not the quality of their work. Facts come from each vendor's website; confirm with the vendor before booking.
| Vendor | Price from | Typical price | Areas served | Event types | Open dates online | Instant quote | Book online | Bookability score | Checked |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rustik Cake Studio | $595 | Hamptons, East End | Weddings | Not shown | Not shown | Yes | 59 / 100 | 2026-11-13 | |
| Brooklyn Cake | $5 | $7 to $12 | New York City, parts of Long Island, Hudson Valley, New Jersey | Weddings, Birthdays | Not shown | Not shown | Not shown | 44 / 100 | 2026-11-13 |
| CMNY Cakes | $8 | Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx | Weddings, Bar and bat mitzvahs, Corporate events, Birthdays, Showers, Other private events | Not shown | Not shown | Not shown | 38 / 100 | 2026-11-13 | |
| My Daughter's Cakes | $700 | Northern New Jersey, New York City, Westchester, Long Island | Weddings, Other private events | Not shown | Not shown | Not shown | 38 / 100 | 2026-11-13 | |
| Pure Sugar, Inc | $200 | Long Island, the Hamptons, Montauk, Manhattan | Weddings, Bar and bat mitzvahs, Other private events | Not shown | Not shown | Not shown | 38 / 100 | 2026-11-13 | |
| petite fleur cake | $10 | Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, Long Island | Weddings, Other private events | Not shown | Not shown | Not shown | 32 / 100 | 2026-11-13 | |
| The Evercake | $245 | NYC, Local New Jersey, the Hamptons | Weddings, Birthdays, Showers, Corporate events, Other private events | Not shown | Not shown | Not shown | 32 / 100 | 2026-11-13 | |
| A Pound & A Half: Cookies and Cupcakes Inc | $30 | Long Island | Not shown | Not shown | Not shown | 27 / 100 | 2026-11-13 | ||
| leannescakes | $250 | Long Island, the 5 boroughs, coastal Connecticut | Weddings, Birthdays, Showers, Other private events | Not shown | Not shown | Not shown | 26 / 100 | 2026-11-13 | |
| Made in Heaven Cakes | $10 | Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, Staten Island | Weddings, Birthdays, Other private events | Not shown | Not shown | Not shown | 26 / 100 | 2026-11-13 | |
| AnnTremet Cake | Not found | Manhattan, Queens, Brooklyn, Long Island | Birthdays | Not shown | Not shown | Not shown | 14 / 100 | 2026-11-13 | |
| Create A Cake | Not found | Long Island | Weddings | Not shown | Not shown | Not shown | 14 / 100 | 2026-11-13 | |
| Cupcakes & Everything Chocolate | Not found | North Fork, Long Island | Weddings, Showers, Birthdays | Not shown | Not shown | Not shown | 14 / 100 | 2026-11-13 | |
| Dortoni Bakery | Not found | Long Island | Weddings | Not shown | Not shown | Not shown | 14 / 100 | 2026-11-13 | |
| Florie's Finales | Not found | Long Island, nationwide | Weddings, Birthdays | Not shown | Not shown | Not shown | 14 / 100 | 2026-11-13 | |
| Mama's Custom Cookies | Not found | nationwide | Weddings, Corporate events, Birthdays | Not shown | Not shown | Not shown | 14 / 100 | 2026-11-13 | |
| Sugar Sugar Custom Cakes | Not found | Long Island, Farmingdale, NY, Quogue, NY | Weddings | Not shown | Not shown | Not shown | 14 / 100 | 2026-11-13 | |
| Copcakes Arresting Appetites | Not found | Long Island | Birthdays, Showers | Not shown | Not shown | Not shown | 11 / 100 | 2026-11-13 | |
| Custom Cakes by Kristy, Inc. | Not found | Long Island | Weddings | Not shown | Not shown | Not shown | 11 / 100 | 2026-11-13 | |
| Diamond Cakes Bakeshop | Not found | Long Island | Birthdays, Showers, Other private events | Not shown | Not shown | Not shown | 11 / 100 | 2026-11-13 | |
| Polka Dot Pound Cake | Not found | Long Island | Birthdays, Showers, Other private events, Corporate events | Not shown | Not shown | Not shown | 11 / 100 | 2026-11-13 | |
| Cakes With Character | Not found | Long Island | Not shown | Not shown | Not shown | 9 / 100 | 2026-11-13 | ||
| The One Cake Shop | Not found | Long Island | Not shown | Not shown | Not shown | 9 / 100 | 2026-11-13 | ||
| Audrey's Fine Baked Goods | Not found | Long Island, New York tri-state area | Birthdays, Weddings | Not shown | Not shown | Not shown | 8 / 100 | 2026-11-13 | |
| Sweet Sweet Sues Custom Cakes | Not found | Staten Island, Manhattan, Brooklyn, Bronx | Weddings, Birthdays, Other private events | Not shown | Not shown | Not shown | 8 / 100 | 2026-11-13 | |
| Sugar Magnolias | Not found | Long Island | Corporate events, Other private events | Not shown | Not shown | Not shown | 5 / 100 | 2026-11-13 | |
| The Cake Don | Not found | Long Island | Weddings, Birthdays | Not shown | Not shown | Not shown | 5 / 100 | 2026-11-13 |
Notes
13 more cake and dessert makers say they serve all of NYC or the whole region without naming Long Island. They are on the page for cake and dessert makers in the New York area.
Related pages
- Cakes and desserts (all)
- Cakes and desserts in Manhattan
- Cakes and desserts in Brooklyn
- Cakes and desserts in Queens
- Cakes and desserts in North Jersey
- Cakes and desserts in Central Jersey
- Cakes and desserts for weddings
- Cakes and desserts for bar and bat mitzvahs
- Cakes and desserts for corporate events
- Cakes and desserts for birthdays
- Cakes and desserts for showers
- Cakes and desserts for other private events
Sorted by fit: vendors with a published price and online booking first, then by score. Being on The Runup does not change the order.