CustomCookies.com: cake and dessert maker in nationwide
CustomCookies.com is a cake and dessert maker that says it serves nationwide. Its website, checked 2026-11-13, lists prices from $5 per item. We found no way to book online on the pages we checked. To get a quote: use the form on its site (https://customcookies.com/products/save-the-date-square-calendar-cookie). Confirm details with the vendor before booking.
Agent Bookability Score: 32 / 100. Last checked 2026-11-13.
This score measures how easily an AI assistant can find, price and book this vendor. It does not rate the quality of their work. The Runup runs this index. The Runup sells booking software that gives vendors the features this score rewards, so vendors on The Runup will score high, and they are labelled "Runs on The Runup". Vendors can score high without The Runup.
Facts
| Fact | Value | Source | Checked |
|---|---|---|---|
| Services | custom decorated cookies, corporate logo cookies, cupcakes, cake pops, macarons | customcookies.com/collections/custom-wedding-cookies "While our custom wedding cookies are a standout, we also offer other sweet options to enhance your dessert table. Include cupcakes, cake pops, macarons, and more to create a visually stunning and deli" | 2026-11-13 |
| Areas served | nationwide | customcookies.com/pages/faq "We ship from our Brooklyn facility all over the United States." | 2026-11-13 |
| Event types | Weddings, Bar and bat mitzvahs, Showers | customcookies.com/pages/events "Custom Wedding Cookies in New York City Custom Bat Mitzvah Cookies in New York City Custom Boy Baby Shower Cookies In New York City" | 2026-11-13 |
| Contact methods | Phone, Chat, Email | customcookies.com/pages/company-logo-cookies "Call Us Need a Quick Reply? Chat with Us Email Us" | 2026-11-13 |
| Cancellation policy | Contact them to see if the order is already in production; if not, the order is cancelled at no cost. | customcookies.com/pages/faq "to see if your order is already in production – if not, we’ll cancel your order at no cost." | 2026-11-13 |
| Booking lead time | Regular-sized local orders 3 days before the event; larger orders ideally 2 weeks before. | customcookies.com/pages/faq "Regular-sized orders should be placed 3 days before the event (for local orders). Larger orders should ideally be placed 2 weeks before the event" | 2026-11-13 |
| Quote request form | Yes | customcookies.com/products/save-the-date-square-calendar-coo "Tell us about your order by filling out the form, and we'll send you quote for your goodies." | 2026-11-13 |
| Price per serving | $5 per item (per decorated cookie, Save the Date Square Calendar Cookie, quantity 12 to 100) | customcookies.com/products/save-the-date-square-calendar-coo "$4.99 Per Decorated cookie Quantity should be between 12 and 100." | 2026-11-13 |
| Tasting | Undecorated sample cookies for taste can be ordered at $5 each; for large orders an exact sample can be photographed free or shipped for a fee. | customcookies.com/pages/company-logo-cookies "Please be aware that the sample will give you a sense of the flavor and texture, but it won't be designed or decorated. Vanilla Ginger Chocolate $5 each" | 2026-11-13 |
| Dietary options | kosher | customcookies.com/pages/faq "Are your products Kosher? Yes, our products are certified by the CRC." | 2026-11-13 |
Not found on the pages we checked: Languages, Starting price, Typical price range, Packages, Minimum spend, Deposit, Shows open dates online, Instant quote, Book online, Minimum order, Delivery and setup.
Score breakdown
- Reachable: 0 / 5
- Readable: 8 / 10 (+3 services stated, +3 areas served stated, +2 event types stated)
- Priced: 18 / 30 (+18 a price is published)
- Availability: 0 / 25
- Bookable: 6 / 30 (+6 online inquiry form)
What would raise it
- Give an instant quote, then let people book online
- Show which dates are open online
- Publish packages or a typical price range
- State your minimums
- Add structured data (schema.org) to your site
- Fix the website so it loads reliably
Website: https://customcookies.com/
Listed on
- Cakes and desserts in the New York area
- Cakes and desserts in Brooklyn
- Cakes and desserts for weddings
- Cakes and desserts for bar and bat mitzvahs
- Cakes and desserts for showers
Similar vendors
- Brooklyn Cake ($5, score 44)
- Sweet Melissa Goodness Cafe ($5, score 32)
- The Vintage Cake ($4, score 32)
- Kimmy's Kakes ($6, score 44)
- Cafe Pierrot ($6, score 32)
Show your score
To show this badge on your website, copy this code:
<a href="https://index.therunup.ai/vendors/customcookies-com/"><img src="https://index.therunup.ai/badge/customcookies-com.svg" alt="Agent Bookability Score 32 of 100" width="238" height="28"></a>
Is this your business? Claim and correct this listing.