How much does a caterer cost per person on Long Island?

Catering on Long Island costs $48 per person on average, and half of the published prices fall between $25 and $95 per person (32 vendors' own published per-person prices, November 2026).

The average here is the median: half of the published prices are below it and half above, so a few very high or very low prices do not pull it. Per-guest prices are how most catering is quoted; the total depends on the menu, service style and guest count, and many caterers set a minimum. These are prices vendors publish on their own websites, not quotes. Each row links to the page the price came from.

VendorPriceWhat the site saysSourceChecked
Perfect Picnic NYC$15 per guestHappy Hour and Party Packages, from $15pp, serves up to 20 peopleperfectpicnicnyc.com/all-picnic-services/picn2026-11-13
Pizza Luca$16 per guestpizza, four Neapolitan styles; $8 half portion; 6 & under ½ pricepizzaluca.com/pizza-luca-catering-menu/2026-11-13
Kitchen Catering Corporation$17 per guestNo Reservations Buffet Package; one tray of food for every ten people; a selection from the pasta menu must be includedkitchencatering.com/no-reservations-buffet-pa2026-11-13
The Barbeque King$20 per guestBBQ Buffet Package, minimum 20 people; plus tax and gratuitythebarbequeking.com/bbq-buffet2026-11-13
The Garage$21 per guestHot Buffet: home cooked specialties, served with tossed or Caesar salads and bakery fresh dinner rollsthegarageeatery.com/catering-menu2026-11-13
Prime Fine Catering$22 per guestPRIME VIP corporate sandwich package, 20 guest minimum; corporate catering for places of business onlycatering.primefinecatering.com/wp-content/upl2026-11-13
John Claude Exclusive Catering$25 per guestCelebrations Wedding Catering Packagejohnclaudeexclusivecatering.com/products/cele2026-11-13
Mangia Buono Caterers$25 per guestFriends & Family Special; pickup or delivery/setup availablemangiabuonocaterers.com/catering-menus-nj-ny-2026-11-13
Big Belly Bbq$26 per guestBig Belly package (most popular), 40-59 guests; sales tax, staff and preparation fee not includedbiggbellybbq.com/bbq-catering-menu/2026-11-13
Chubs Food Truck$30 per guestall five menu items; 40 guest minimum, plus a $200 chef feechubsfoodtruck.com/faq/2026-11-13
Vegan Catering Nyc$32 per guestbreakfast, choose 3 menu itemsvegancateringnyc.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/2026-11-13
Pies-on Wheels$35 per guestwedding package starting pricepiesonwheels.com/lets-have-a-party2026-11-13
Ronnie's Catering and BBQ$45 per guestRonnie's Pig Roast, starting at, per adult; does NOT include the full service, tax or gratuityronniescateringbbq.com/bbq-packages/ronnies-p2026-11-13
Bolands Caterers$45 per guestfull catering packages starting price, all inclusivebolandscaterers.com/2026-11-13
Platinum Party$45 per guestBronze Menu buffet or dual plated sit down; excludes staff, rentals, bar package, admin fee and NYS sales taxplatinumparty.com/_files/ugd/b890de_ef0ed80a22026-11-13
The Culinary Studio$45 per guestSpring Party Menu (April through May), plus tax; does not include rental equipment or service staff; based on a minimum theculinarystudio.com/wp-content/uploads/20262026-11-13
Hibachi 4 World$50 per guestper adult, guest selects 2 proteins; $25 per child (13 and under); $500 minimum per partyhibachi4world.com/booking/2026-11-13
Hibachi Take Home$50 per guestper adult, 2 proteins with salad, fried rice and vegetables; $25 per kid 12 and under; gratuity not includedhibachitakeover.com/booking/2026-11-13
hibachiumami$50 per guest2 Protein Option; includes side salad, hibachi vegetables and fried rice; kids (13 & under) $30 per child, ages 3 and unhibachiumami.com/menu2026-11-13
Hibachi At Home US$55 per guestper adult, 2 proteins with edamame, fried rice and vegetables; $30 per kid under 10; price may vary by locationhibachiathomeus.com/2026-11-13
Long Island Lobster Bake$55 per guestClassic BBQ package, minimum 25 guestslongislandlobsterbake.com/bbq-packages2026-11-13
Tokyo Hibachi Catering$59 per guestbase price; all fees included except traveling fee and gratuitytokyohibachicatering.com/faq-hibachi-catering2026-11-13
Insatiable Eats Catering$66 per guestClassic Buffet, 100+ guests, 5 hrs; $74 per guest for 50 to 74 guestsinsatiableeats.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/112026-11-13
Rapt Hospitality – Craft Catering & Events$95 per guestCoursed Meals, $95 to $200 per guestraptny.com/start-planning/pricing2026-11-13
Susan's Weddings$95 per gueststarting price for full-service wedding cateringsusansweddings.com/wedding-catering-nyc/2026-11-13
Kombert Caterers Inc$125 per guestper adult above 100 people in the mitzvah party package; $95 per childkombertcaterers.com/docs/KombertCaterers_mitz2026-11-13
East End Clambakes$137 per guestClassic Clambake Menu; excludes labor, gratuity, sales tax and party rentalseastendclambakes.com/classic-menu2026-11-13
Ginger Man Catering$150 per guestMenu Number 1 Sit Down Dinner, minimum 100 people; $175 per person under 100; $4,200 flat fee under 20 peoplegingermancatering.com/menu-number-1-sit-down-2026-11-13
Creative Courses Catering$165 per guestwedding package, plus NYS sales tax and 20% admin fee; some premium dishes carry a supplementcreativecoursescatering.com/weddings2026-11-13
Christopher Michael Catering$175 per guestall inclusive; per person includes dishware, glassware, silverware, linens, tables and chairs, cooking equipmentchristophermichaelcatering.com/menus/2026-11-13
Caribbean Pearl Caterers$190 per guestThe Carimi wedding package, food and beverages includedcaribbeanpearlcaterers.com/wedding-packages2026-11-13
Private Chef Chris LaVecchia$250 per guestminimum per-person investment for a tasting menu experience, typically starting around $250 per guestchefchrislavecchia.com/faq2026-11-13

All caterers, with whole-event prices and how to book: the caterers list. All figures: the NYC Event Price Index. How we collect prices.